afaqs! Techafaqs! Campus The Mobile Indian Jobswitch Kulzy

Points of View

Points of View: Whose line is it anyway?

In the ideas business, where brainstorming takes place in large groups, how to do agencies assign creative credit?

Karan Rawat, founder and ECD, AutumnWinter Communications & Design

The problem starts when a campaign becomes big and starts winning awards. Once the idea sells, they go on to tell the world that it was cracked by them and they forget that an agency is all about team work. This happens because of inexperience and immaturity.

Once an idea is cracked, it goes through the process of getting approvals from seniors, who then take it to a different level, thereby converting a good idea into a big idea. Similarly, when a senior comes up with an idea and takes the team's help to execute it, it also becomes the team's idea.

Look at any credit list for an ad or film - it's always a long laundry list. This happens because each member of the team has contributed to the idea, from the source of the idea itself to its final execution.

If an idea is cracked during a discussion or brainstorming session, a single person cannot take the credit, because one idea leads to another, making everybody in the room the 'owner' of that idea. An idea can come from anywhere - the creative department, your CEO or a client servicing intern. It is what the agency does with the idea that counts.

Malvika Mehra, NCD and executive vice president, Grey India

Read on...
More POV's
Goafest 2014: The Abby jury speaks on the quality of work
Goafest 2014: How is Goafest relevant for marketers?
Goafest 2014: Quick Bytes From Marketing Biggies
Goafest 2014: Does Goafest need to bring back the Scam Committee?
Goafest 2014: Is 'integration' a buzzword or the only way forward?
Goafest 2014: Who gains at the Goafest?
Goafest 2014: What is the biggest 'selling point' of the Abby Awards?
POV: Can Media and Money Change Football in India?
POV: To what extent has the media coaxed voting?
POV: Will interest in political news decline after the elections?
IPL and General Election: Competing for public attention?
POV: Should brands associated with IPL be worried?
Learning from the SpiceJet dance
POV: Do Creative Agencies Neglect Print Ads?
Points of View: Crime on TV - Fiction vs Non-fiction
Points of View: Bridge Over Troubled Water
Points of View: Is the new IRS being unjustly bashed?
Points of View: How will another ratings black-out impact the TV business?
Points of View: Will brands experience the 'AAP Effect'?
Points of View: Is singing reality a dying genre?
Points of View: Are creative awards losing relevance?
  • POV: Will online viewing hurt television?

    Media Publishing & Television

    While there is no study that demonstrates what the causal impact of online viewing is on TV viewership, afaqs! talks to industry experts to learn more about the same.

  • POV: Has brand IIT weakened?


    Given that hundreds of students have secured yet rejected IIT seats, this year, because they don't trust the newer IITs, we asked education experts and IIT alumni, who currently occupy top media/marketing positions whether brand IIT has weakened.

  • POV: Is brand IPL in a spot?

    Media Publishing & Television

    Is the impact of spot fixing on brand IPL big enough for it to struggle for advertisers in the next year? afaqs! explores.

  • POV: Gross or net billing?

    Media Publishing & Television

    While the discussion between agencies and broadcasters continues, advertising has been temporarily pulled off from television screens, the only exception being made for IPL. afaqs! spoke to stakeholders on their views.

  • POV: Will Facebook Home change the game for mobile marketing?

    Digital & Mobile Marketing

    Will the app for Android phones get Indian marketers to think about mobile marketing in a different way?

Daily NewsLetter