Remember the 2016 Ramadan ad by Surf Excel Pakistan that crossed a million views in less than a week? This Ramadan too, Arun Iyer's team at Lowe Lintas, Mumbai, has created a campaign for the brand. Titled #NekiEkIbadat, the ad is along very similar lines as last year's ad - a little boy goes out of his way to help someone and of course, soils his kurta in the bargain.
He says, "No, nothing like that. See, 'Daag Ache Hain' is a broad enough platform. We are doing 'goodness to others' through this campaign, we have done 'learnings of life' and we have done 'demonstrating of great values'. So it's a broad enough platform. We have to keep the brand, the essence of the brand and the cultural truth about the festival in mind, so it is the combination of all three that leads us to do something like this. There is a cultural reality to Pakistan and to the festival and to what people think around the festival and we had to keep all those things in mind."
We asked our digital experts to compare Surf Excel's 2016 and 2017 ads. This is what they had to say...
Mark McDonald, head of creative - Mumbai, DigitasLBi India, a digital agency from the house of Publicis Sapient, says, "It's always tough to do a follow up of a popular, well liked ad, but I think Surf Excel has done a decent job. Keep in mind that for consumers, it's been be year since they saw the last ad, so I'd evaluate it on its own merits first. And I think the new commercial presses all the right buttons in terms of execution and casting and holds its own."
He adds, "Personally, I think the original edges out the new commercial, purely from the perspective of the situation chosen. I think helping out the samosa cart vendor in the manner in which the kids did, was a nice, relatable way to bring in the aspect of stains. But there's not much difference between the two. I think this is a good follow-up."
The idea and insight are pretty much the same across both films. It's almost like flogging the same theme - 'madad', 'neki' - both are in a very similar zone, feel some experts. Is this inevitable? Is it a case of being bound by the brief? Does the tagline itself barricade creativity or could the team have stretched the envelope more?
D'Silva says, "Well it is but another interpretation of the topic... when you listen to a song, you don't like it because it's a love song, you do because it's a unique expression of a love song... the same is the case here."
McDonald says, "Given the context and occasion, you're bound to play within the same areas creatively, and that's not necessarily a bad thing. With Surf's overall positioning of 'Daag Acche Hain', I don't think the brief would be limiting in that respect. Of course, if I see something very similar next year, then I would start to question the need for a fresh perspective. But as of now, I think the second rendition of Surf Excel's Ramzan ad is a good follow-up and does the job."First Published : May 31, 2017