Anindita Sarkar

Television - Time to Change

Digitisation and TRAI regulations are all set to hit the television business soon. How will it affect broadcasters and advertisers?

Television - Time to Change
The Indian television space, if not exactly in turbulence, is certainly facing an upheaval. Digitisation of cable television - which has just been postponed - is only a few months away. A TRAI (Telecom Regulatory Authority of India) ruling some time back laid out a cap on ads shown on a channel to 10+2 minutes (10 minutes for ads and 2 for own promos) in an hour. Though this has been stayed by TDSAT - Telecom Disputes Settlement & Appellate Tribunal - the debate continues to rage.

Despite being postponed once (stakeholders reacted differently - see Points of View after Cover Story), it is almost certain that the digitisation in the metros will happen by November 1. The rest of the country can expect to be digitised by 2014. In what ways is this going to impact the business?

More niches will appear

In the analog world, when a viewer switches on his TV set, she has to invariably surf through channels to reach the final destination, which is why the channels race to occupy a place among the first few. But the bandwidth for prime and color bands (these enjoy extremely good reception quality) is limited to 11 channels. Of these, Doordarshan (DD) takes up three. The rest are taken by the biggies. For a new channel, the next option is the S-Band or UHF band, to enter which a channel has to pay an additional premium, also referred to as the "displacement premium".

Generally, a broadcaster may have to shell out Rs. 65-70 crore (source: Chrome Data Analytics & Media) for launching a new channel with a 100 per cent HSM presence on S-band. If the new entrant wants to be on prime band, it could have to shell out 50 per cent more. Says LV Krishnan, CEO, TAM Media Research, "GECs find pride of place on prime bands because of the content pull they enjoy. A viewer often scrolls through many channels before reaching the final destination. This results in audience wastage." Digitisation will reduce this substantially.

Carriage costs will fall

For now, the real pain for many channels is not the lack of revenue from advertising but the huge cost of distribution that has killed business models. Once the analog network starts to fade and is replaced by digital, this ‘killer' cost will disappear. As digitisation takes over, carriage costs (money paid to cable operators) could come down by as much as 50 per cent. This is because quality of reception will be equally good across channels, irrespective of whether it is at No 9 or No 99.

According to Chrome, the cost per contact (CPC) paid by a channel to reach out to its customer is, say, Rs. 20. With digitisation, the bandwidth capacity will rise to 500 channels, which means the CPC comes down to one-fifth or Rs. 4. As a result, the premium paid by broadcasters will also fall.

Viewers' choices increase

Specialised channels exist even today. But they do not get their due because of lack of transparency and representation in viewership (owing to sampling constraints). They are at a disadvantage in an analog scenario where they are mostly placed on lower bands with poor reception capacity.

Television - Time to Change
"Post digitisation, customers can choose and pay for the channel they want to watch. This transparency will result in focused channels getting the economic benefit which was missing," says Pankaj Krishna, founder, Chrome Data Analytics and Media. The sampling constraints will also become less stressful for advertiser as well as broadcaster.

Consumer behaviour is already showing signs of change in the semi-digitised world. In Mumbai or Delhi, where 25 per cent of the market is digitised, TAM witnessed new patterns. For instance, more viewers are glued to genres of their choice and landing straight on their favourite stations, while time spent on specific genres is increasing too. TAM is now doubling its metro samples to 60 per cent. This will help broadcasters and advertisers to not only understand content consumption patterns but also target their programming and brand communication well. Does this also mean that the importance of GECs will come down?

Not really. According to experts, GECs will continue to remain the bread and butter for established networks. This is because the main contributors to GEC viewership are women and they will continue to watch. In fact, with an increase in the revenue pie (through reduced carriage fee and increased subscription), the network will begin to spend more on its GEC content. The dogfight, if any, of the digitised future will be between second-rung GECs and other channels.

Additionally, a channel might be in preferable packs on some operators' menus and not-so-popular packs on others. "In the latter case, the channel will have to micro-market in that operator's constituency to ensure that viewers still buy the channel on the not-so-popular pack or buy that channel a-la-carte," says Atul Phadnis, Founder-CEO, What's-On-India.

Only the fit will survive

Interestingly, since there will be less audience wastage or duplication and more opportunities of sampling for other genres, the ratings of a GEC may eventually fall or stagnate. This could mean that it will not be able to increase its ad rates much.

Television - Time to Change
So, for instance, if Star Plus, which clocks Rs. 800-1,000 crore, is unable to move beyond its average 275-300 GRP mark, it will fail to increase its ad rates substantially. Therefore, the network, which is heavily dependent on Star Plus' revenues, would have to take the horizontal growth route if it intends to shore up its overall income.

Result? There will be more opportunities to increase subscription revenue through specialised content and channels. Not to forget GECs will continue to enjoy their pre-eminent position since contribute 40-50 per cent of the total subscription revenues that their networks raise. There will be a better balance in subscription too - from 80:20 ratio in favour of advertising to a 65:35 ratio, which is also the global norm. "Survival will depend on how fit the channel is. All 800 channels will never be profitable together," says Vidhu Sagar, executive vice president, Carat Media India.

Channels will become brands

With the increase in the availability of more channels that work on a more focused domain, TV channels will eventually have to emerge as a brand, supported by a definitive proposition. This means that a Satyamev Jayate and a Star Plus will not be able to stand as two different products with individual propositions but rather, quite like an FMCG, as one singular entity with a broader unique offering. As channels emerge as brands, the methods of marketing will have to change. Marketing today ensures that the distribution, content, on-air promos, are in sync. Now, it will become more defined and grow on the costs saved on distribution. Which means that if there are 10-20 people in the distribution department of a channel, some could be shifted to marketing.

Television - Time to Change
Marketing for the brand will also become more important because of a TRAI clause. According to the Authority, all channels will be available at an a la carte price which will be much lower than before. Marketing will have to become profile-led and centered on focused geographies, than being GRP-heavy. In analog, second rung channels could push themselves by paying off the cable operator. In the changed circumstances, these channels can get in only if the household wants them in or go free to air. So the brand becomes critical, its familiarity becomes critical and its image and reputation become critical. "Brand managers will have to take the driver's seat. Consumers will be studied, understood and content built around them. Today, content is created first and then promoted across the targeted audience group," says Paritosh Joshi, ex-CEO, Star CJ.

Ad rates will be affected

The biggest hurdle facing advertisers is the proposed 12-minutes-in-an-hour cap on ads. This will push up ad rates because there are few shows or channels that command high ratings. So earlier, if a channel was selling 100 spots for Rs. 10 each and made Rs. 1,000, it would now have to sell 50 spots at Rs. 20 to match that. The viewer is happy too. Not everyone agrees it is so simple.

Television - Time to Change
"If there is near perfect competition then it will be difficult even for a GEC to increase rates as someone else will blink. But if there is a relative gap between players, then the top channels will be able to hike rates at the expense of smaller channels," says L S Krishnan, thought leader, Amagi.

Meanwhile, the frequencies could also even out the process. If, for example, an advertiser is operating on a 60:8 reach and frequency ratio (wherein the brand is reaching out to 60 per cent of the audience with each viewer getting exposed to the brand's ad eight times in that period), market forces could force the channel to reduce the exposure to four or even less.

A hike in ad rates could eliminate the non-serious advertiser - there are Hindi national news channels that operate at an effective rate of Rs. 250 for a 10-second spot. But many believe that local brands such as pan masalas, cement or innerwear having ‘tasted blood' will continue to stay, even if rates go up.

Advertisers will Innovate

The changed circumstances will force advertisers to innovate. Ad creatives could also undergo change in more ways than one. Most of the ads that come out range from a 1 minute version to 30 seconds or 20 seconds. The mandate could change to a 30, 20, 10 and even a 5. But here is the dig. TRAI regulations suggest that ads have to be full screen. Part-screen and drop down ad will not be permitted. So, innovations will also be under pressure.

Indian advertisers could do an Apple here. When the iPad hit stores in April 2010, it was heavily marketed. Just three days before D-day, iPad was the star of the 19th episode of ABC TV's Modern Family. It was a key part of the plot as the family tried to buy the father an iPad for his birthday, which coincided with the device's launch day.

Digitisation will bring in value-added services such as VOD and broadband. Experts foresee that television will, over time, be less sold in slots and more as a part of programming, across media. Content properties will also have footprints across TV, YouTube, Facebook and other media such as radio. Convergence will become the route to sell. It will now be TV+digital+mobile+social media.

Says Mahesh Murthy, CEO, Pinstorm, "MTV Roadies manages a TVR of 0.4 or less. That means it's seen, at its peak, in 4.5 lakh homes. Assuming one teenager a home, that's a peak viewership of less than five lakh. But the same show has 10 times the fan base on its FB page. On the revenue front though, it's 99 per cent TV and 1 per cent online. This dichotomy will make less sense for advertiser and consumer in the years ahead."

Coming back to the beginning, the tremors that are about to hit television in India could do more good than bad. Watch this space.